Friday, December 7, 2018

I. COMPARISONS, A LITTLE-USED TOOL FOR HISTORY


 SIMILAR ECONOMIES, SIMILAR THREATS,
SIMILAR REACTIONS 

Take kings' violent response to ascendant producers
in  19th-century Dahomey and 17th-century France 

 In France,
Louis XIV's eliminating Protestants
eliminates the producers themselves 

Dragonnade by Maurice Leloir in Le  Roy Soleil by T. Cabu, 1931


In Dahomey, 
the monarch sacrifices 300 slaves
to keep producers from buying them 

Dahomey human sacrifice in 1853, "Le Tour du Monde"
-- Analyzed by Claude Meillassoux,
Ostentation, destruction, reproduction , "Économies et sociétés,"
 1968, II, 4, 760-766


Beyond Marx:
The struggle of 
"slaves against masters, peasants against lords"
yields to that of rising commercial forces 
and the authorities they menace.

To be continued.

*      *      *

Wednesday, December 5, 2018

HINTERLANDS REACT TO SUDDEN GROWTH


THE RUDIMENTARY ECONOMIES 
OF PRE-COLONIAL AFRICA AND PRE-INDUSTRIAL FRANCE 
MAKE THE IMPACT OF GROWTH EASY TO DISCERN

Paris and Timbuktu were the main centers
north of the Alps or in West Africa,
but they were isolated
 in comparison with the Italian towns
and insignificant next to those
 of the Middle East, India and China 

• By 1450 France
had recovered from the plague
and the ravages of the Hundred Years' War.
Economic growth was gradual
and gently-centralizing power contained it

 Charles VI greets Louis II of Anjou near the Saint Michel gate, Chronicle of Jean Froissart, about 1390

 Paris: the north-south route looks like a country path.  

 By 1850 
sub-Saharan trade and production were expanding
and states able to keep them in check
had emerged in the most commercial regions
(in Northern Nigeria and west of Lake Chad) 

"Arrival at Timbuktu," Travels and discoveries in North and Central Africa by Henry Barth, 1855 (color / Internet)
Timbuktu: soldiers precede the caravane because authority is weak and routes unsafe. 

• But upheavals were on the way

° In western Europe,
the geographic discoveries of the end of the 15th century
would bring unprecedented growth and social cataclysm.

° In West Africa,
growth had been relatively slow because climate belts
 discouraged the spread of agricultural improvements,
but after 1850 the end of the Atlantic slave trade
would turn breezes of change into hurricanes.
 -- Climate belts:
A popular history of the world, from the stone age to the new millenium,
by Chris Harmon, "The African civilizations," 1999.
A rare history to see political change as the result of economic evolution.
 .
End of this beginning.

*      *      *